Text

CHAPTER TWO / 1995

How to Build a Wall

The trouble with the sea, Elias Rowan had decided, was that it did not understand the difference between an accident and a mistake.

An accident was something you couldn't have helped. A mistake was something you should have thought of first. Grown-ups used the words as if they meant the same thing, particularly when a glass broke or someone walked mud through the kitchen, but Elias knew there was a distinction. If the sea ruined his castle because the waves were unusually large, that would be an accident. If he had built the wall too low, it would be his mistake.

He had therefore built the wall very high.

It encircled a fortress of four towers and a central keep, all made with the blue bucket that had lost its handle last summer. The sand nearest the tide was darker and stronger. Elias had chosen that sand after testing three other kinds. He'd pressed the wall smooth with the back of a plastic spade and reinforced the outer edge with pebbles. He'd dug a moat, but only a shallow one. Too deep a moat would weaken the ground underneath.

Kit sat beside him on the beach, eating the last of a packet of crisps and watching him work.

"It needs a river," Kit said.

"It's got a moat."

"A river coming in from the sea. We could let the water through here and out the other side."

"That would defeat the point."

"What's the point?"

"To stop the water getting in."

Kit considered the fortress. He had sand in his eyebrows and an orange crisp stuck to his thumb. Nothing that happened on a beach seemed to worry him. He could lose a shoe, an argument or an entire sandwich and still find something interesting to do before the tide turned.

"But if you let the water in," Kit said, "we could have boats."

"It's a castle, not a harbour."

"It could be both."

"A castle with a river running through the middle would be a very bad castle."

"Maybe the people in it like fishing."

"They'll drown."

"They're made of sand, Elias."

Elias pressed another pebble into the wall and tried not to feel irritated.

It was the last Saturday before the autumn term began, and Saltmere beach was crowded with families pretending the summer had a little longer to live. Wind pulled at towels and carried the smell of frying onions from the promenade. A man with a metal detector walked in solemn little lines beneath the sea wall. Two dogs chased the same tennis ball while their owners shouted contradictory instructions. Beyond them the North Sea moved under a pale sky, folding grey water into white foam.

The sea wall ran along the edge of town, taller than a man, the concrete stained at the base where waves struck it in winter. Elias liked the wall. It had been built by people who understood that water was not entitled to go wherever it pleased. His father liked it too, though he said there was no such thing as a wall you could stop thinking about once it was finished.

"You ought to open the gate," Kit said.

"There isn't a gate."

"Exactly. That's the problem."

"See?" Elias said.

Kit made a disappointed noise and began digging his own channel on the other side of the beach. He worked quickly and carelessly, scooping sand with both hands. His channel bent around a stone and passed through a small arch before ending in a pool that contained an unhappy-looking shell.

"That's not going to work," Elias told him.

"It might."

"It won't. It slopes the wrong way."

"Water can go round corners."

"Not uphill."

"We'll see."

Elias wanted to explain exactly why they would not see, but a larger wave was arriving. He leaned forward, watching its advancing edge. His wall stood level. He had built the towers back from the shore, placed the heavier stones low down and left no gap big enough for a finger.

The wave reached the outer pebbles, hesitated, then pushed between them. A small dark line appeared under the eastern tower.

"It's getting in," Kit said, delighted.

"No it isn't."

The dark line widened. Elias jammed his spade into it, trying to close the opening. The wave came over the wall at two points at once. Water filled the moat, climbed the keep and took the southern tower apart with a quiet slumping sound. Then it was past, carrying away a pebble and a small flag made from a cocktail stick.

For a second Elias could only stare.

He had expected the wall to hold. In the private picture he had made of the afternoon, the tide would rise, Kit would become impressed, and every other sandcastle on the beach would collapse while his remained untouched. It had been a very satisfying picture.

Instead the wall looked as if someone had trodden on a cake.

"You needed somewhere for it to go," Kit said.

"I needed more sand."

"My river's working!"

It was. The retreating wave had found Kit's crooked little channel and was running through it, making a silver thread around the stone. The pool at the end had filled. The unhappy shell was floating.

Kit laughed, not at Elias but at the sight of his own ridiculous engineering doing something neither boy had entirely expected. He turned to share it.

Elias took his spade and flattened what remained of the central keep.

"I'm going home."

"We only just got here."

"It's finished."

Kit watched him stuff the spade into the broken bucket. "We could build another."

"What's the point?" he asked.

Kit looked down at the water moving through his channel. "I liked building it."

It seemed such a stupid answer that Elias had nothing to say.

On Monday morning the school smelled of floor polish, wet coats and the particular misery of new exercise books that nobody had yet been allowed to write in.

Mrs Pritchard, their teacher, had put a sheet of coloured paper on every desk. Across the top it said OUR COAST. There was a drawing of a harbour, four photographs of rock pools and a list of words they would be learning during the term.

"We're doing the sea," Kit whispered, dropping into the chair beside him. "That's you sorted, then."

"We're not doing the sea. We're doing coasts."

"You can tell her about your castle."

"Shut up."

"It was a very good castle. For about twelve seconds."

Elias slid his pencil tin to the middle of the table so Kit wouldn't knock it off. At the front of the room a boy stood beside Mrs Pritchard. He wore a navy jumper that looked too warm for September and held the straps of his schoolbag in both fists.

"This is Daniel Price," Mrs Pritchard said. "He's just moved to Saltmere. I hope you'll all make him welcome."

Mrs Pritchard found a spare chair at the table in front of Elias and Kit. When Daniel sat down, he arranged the corners of his paper carefully with the edge of the desk. Elias noticed, with a complicated feeling of approval, that he liked things straight.

Mrs Pritchard then asked them to read aloud from a small book about rock pools. The passage travelled from desk to desk, each child taking a few sentences. When it reached Daniel, he sat very straight and gripped the book so tightly that the cover bowed.

"Beneath the seaweed," he read, "are limpets, crabs and sea..."

He stopped.

Elias knew the next word. It was in the picture beside the paragraph, a flower-shaped creature attached to a rock. His father had shown him one, and had explained that it was an animal although it looked like something a gardener might plant.

Daniel tried again. "Sea an-enemies."

There were two little laughs from the back. They might have disappeared if nobody had encouraged them. Then Elias made a noise, a sudden sharp bark of amusement, and Kit snorted beside him. Several children joined in.

Daniel's face changed colour in patches. He kept staring at the page as though he could make the word become smaller. Mrs Pritchard told the class to be quiet and supplied the pronunciation. She made Elias say it too.

"Anemone," he said perfectly.

"Thank you. Now perhaps we'll remember that being quick at a word isn't the same as being kind. Daniel, would you like to carry on?"

Daniel nodded without looking up. His next sentence came out so softly that nobody could hear the end.

At morning break, Kit tried to make Elias laugh again by whispering, "Beware the sea enemies."

It worked for half a second. Then Elias glanced towards the window. Daniel was standing near the model harbour display, alone, holding a packet of biscuits he had not opened.

"Don't," Elias said.

Kit looked surprised. "You laughed first."

"I know."

"Then why am I in trouble?"

"You're not."

But Elias could not explain why the joke had sounded different when someone else told it. He had not wanted Daniel to look the way he had looked. He had wanted everyone to laugh, yes, but not for the laughter to settle on a person and stay there.

After break Mrs Pritchard announced a short test on place value. Elias felt instantly better. Numbers were reliable. Seven hundred and four was seven hundred and four, whatever anyone thought about it. If someone wrote it incorrectly, Mrs Pritchard could put a neat mark beside the answer and show them where they'd gone wrong.

Unfortunately a bottle of orange squash had leaked in Elias's schoolbag. He had pushed the tin back inside after break without checking the bottom, and now the pencils lay in a sugary puddle. Two points snapped when he tried to write. A third scratched a faint grey line and refused to improve. He opened the sharpener and found its blade choked with wet shavings.

"Five minutes," said Mrs Pritchard.

Elias felt heat climb his neck. The questions were easy. He could see the answers in his head. He had only written his name.

A hand appeared over the edge of the desk.

Daniel was holding out a yellow pencil.

"It's dry," he whispered.

Elias stared at it. The pencil had a little dent near the eraser where someone had pressed too hard on the wood. It wasn't new. It was simply usable.

"Thanks," Elias said.

Daniel put it on the desk and turned back towards his paper.

There was no smile, no reproach, no expectation that Elias would say anything else. Daniel had seen a boy without a pencil and had given him one. He had not apparently consulted the record of the morning first.

Elias finished the test with two minutes to spare. He got every answer right, though he made one digit too large in his haste and had to erase it. When Mrs Pritchard collected the papers, he held the yellow pencil out to Daniel.

"You can have it till the end of the day," Daniel whispered. "I've got another."

Elias opened his mouth to say something about the reading lesson. He imagined himself saying, I wasn't laughing at you, which was not quite true. Or, Everyone was laughing, which was true and sounded worse. Or perhaps, Sorry, which was a very short word for the weight now sitting beneath his ribs.

Instead he said, "All right."

The pencil remained on his desk, dividing the afternoon into before and after.

By Wednesday the class had begun building a model of Saltmere harbour. Mrs Pritchard had brought in cardboard boxes, blue paper and a bag of clean gravel from her garden. The children were allowed to make buildings and boats, but the water had to be drawn rather than real because, she said, she had not become a teacher to supervise a swimming pool.

Daniel brought a boat from home.

It was a small fishing vessel made from a piece of hollowed softwood, with a short mast, a red-and-white paper cabin and a tiny name painted in blue on the bow. The letters were not perfectly even. Two had slanted towards the waterline. The hull had a darker patch where it had been sanded smooth, and a pin held a thread from mast to stern.

"My grandad showed me," Daniel said when Mrs Pritchard asked. He spoke softly, but Elias could hear pride beneath the words. "He used to work on boats."

"Did he make it with you?"

"He made the first one. I did this one."

Mrs Pritchard cleared a place at the edge of the harbour display. "Then it deserves pride of place."

Elias wanted to ask whether the boat would float. He had been thinking about buoyancy since the weekend, and the little vessel seemed top-heavy. The cabin was large compared with the hull, and the mast leaned a fraction to port. His father had once told him that a boat could be beautiful on a shelf and useless on water. It depended on where its weight sat.

Daniel placed it among the cardboard buildings. The little blue name, ROSE, faced the classroom.

"It's good," Elias said when Daniel passed him on the way to the glue table.

Daniel paused. "Thanks."

"You might want to put something underneath. To stop it tipping."

Daniel glanced back. "It's not going in the sea."

"I know. I'm just saying."

"It stood up at home."

When the class went out for lunch, Elias returned to collect the pencil he had left on the windowsill. Kit had already gone, shouting something about football. The room was empty except for the smell of drying paste and a clock that ticked much more loudly without children beneath it.

The ROSE stood on the harbour display.

Elias crouched beside it. From this angle he could see that the mast was indeed leaning. A little piece of blue tack under the keel would steady it. He found a lump in the craft tray and reached across the model streets, trying to lift the boat without disturbing a row of cardboard houses.

The thread snagged on the point of a cardboard chimney.

He pulled gently. The chimney bent, then the boat slipped from his fingers and struck the edge of the desk. He heard the small dry snap of the mast. The cabin separated from the hull and skidded across the floor. The pin came free and vanished beneath a cupboard.

He dropped to his knees and gathered the fragments. The mast had splintered where it met the deck. The roof of the cabin was creased. A flake of paint had come away from the R, leaving a pale nick in the name.

He tried to slot the mast back into its hole. It fell out. He pressed the cabin into place; it tipped onto one side. The more he handled the pieces, the more fragile they became.

He could go and find Mrs Pritchard. He could explain that he had been trying to help. He could say it had been an accident.

But then he imagined Daniel's face, the same patches of colour as on Monday, and Mrs Pritchard asking why Elias had touched the boat at all. He pictured the whole class listening while he explained about weight and balance. It was the sort of explanation which, in his head, made everything perfectly clear. Spoken aloud, it would begin with words he didn't want to say: I picked it up without asking.

He placed the fragments in an old biscuit tin beneath the display and pushed the lid almost shut. He would fix it that night. Then nothing would need to be explained.

When the class returned, Mrs Pritchard noticed the empty space immediately.

"Where's Daniel's boat?"

Elias stared down at a worksheet. The numbers printed upon it looked suddenly meaningless.

"Was it moved to the windowsill?" Mrs Pritchard asked.

Nobody answered. Daniel stood up and checked both sides of the table. He moved slowly, as if the boat might be there after all if he looked carefully enough.

"It was right here," he said.

"We'll find it," she said.

After school he lingered while Mrs Pritchard spoke to a parent. As soon as the room was empty, he slipped the boat pieces into his bag. The biscuit tin remained beneath the display, carrying no evidence except a faint ring of red paint on its bottom.

Kit caught him at the gate.

"What's that?"

"Nothing."

"Your bag's got a mast sticking out."

Elias pushed it down. "It's something I'm fixing."

Kit's expression altered. "Is it Daniel's?"

Elias said nothing.

"Did you break it?"

"Not on purpose."

Kit considered this. "Then why didn't you tell him?"

"Because I'll fix it."

"You could tell him and fix it."

"Then he'll be angry."

"He might be."

"If I fix it first, he won't have to be."

For once Kit did not seem to have a joke ready. He looked past Elias towards the school doors, where Daniel was leaving with his bag held close against his side.

"I don't think that's how it works," Kit said.

Elias turned away before Kit could ask him what he meant.

Peter Rowan was waiting at the harbour steps with his sleeves rolled up and a coil of rope at his feet. He had been helping someone replace a rusted fastening on a small workboat, and there was a dark smear of grease along his wrist. Elias loved the way his father could arrive home smelling of diesel, seaweed and hot metal without ever appearing to notice.

"Your mum says you've been quiet," Peter said.

"I'm not quiet."

"No?"

"I'm talking now."

"Fair point."

Peter sat on the third step above the water, leaving room beside him. The harbour was settling into evening. Gulls quarrelled over scraps on the quay. A fishing boat crept between the harbour arms, its engine making a low, regular thudding sound. Elias could see the line of old stains on the stone steps, dark bands above the tide, each one marking where the water had reached at a different time.

"What are those?" Elias asked, though he already knew some of the answer.

"Tide marks. Some are left by weed, some by salt, some by all sorts of muck in the water. They're not exact, mind."

"That one looks high."

"Winter storm a few years back. Water came right over the landing."

"Could you build the steps higher?"

"You could. Then we'd need a longer ladder for the boats."

"What if you made the wall thicker?"

"In some places that's sensible. In others you just send the water somewhere you didn't want it."

Peter drew a line with one finger through a patch of dust on the step. He marked the harbour wall, then a narrow gap for the boats and a rough circle for the basin.

"When water comes in here, it needs somewhere to go. You can put a barrier up, but you ought to know what happens when it comes round the end. That's why people measure tides, not just the height of concrete."

Elias thought of the sandcastle. He had almost told his father about it on Saturday, but the memory was still unpleasant.

"Kit wanted to make a river through my wall," he said.

"Did he?"

"It was a stupid idea."

"Was it?"

"A wall's supposed to stop water."

Peter nodded. "A wall can be useful."

"Exactly."

"Provided you remember the sea is real."

Elias looked up at him.

"I knew the sea was real."

"I know you did. But sometimes you build a thing on paper, or in your head, and start believing the world will keep to the plan. The sea won't. Doesn't read signs, doesn't answer complaints."

"Kit's river didn't stop it either."

"Perhaps it wasn't meant to stop it."

Peter picked up a short length of frayed rope. He began threading one end back through the other, tightening the strands into a tidy eye splice.

"There's a difference," he said after a while, "between making something strong and pretending it can't break."

"But if it does break, you can fix it."

"Sometimes."

"You can fix most things."

Peter laughed, though not in the way Kit laughed. "I'd better not let your mother hear you say that. She's got a list of things I've been going to fix since you were born."

"If you fix something really well," he asked, "does it matter how it broke?"

Peter stopped working on the rope. For a moment the harbour sounds occupied the space between them.

"Depends what broke," he said.

"A boat."

"A real one?"

"A model."

"Whose model?"

Elias looked at the old stains on the steps. "Someone from school."

"You helping him?"

"I'm going to."

"Feel that."

Elias ran his thumb over the tightened strands. The join was smooth and firm. You could see where the rope had been worked, but it looked stronger for it.

"Could you make it so nobody knew there'd been a break?" he asked.

"Not in that bit of rope. You'd have to replace it."

"Wouldn't that be better?"

"Not always. Depends who's trusting it. If I were putting my weight on it, I'd rather know where the join was."

Elias let the rope fall back into his father's hand.

On the way home they stopped at a bakery because Peter had promised Lena something for tea and forgotten until they passed the shop. He bought two iced buns and a loaf of bread, then said the buns were for his wife and the bread was a distraction in case she noticed one was missing. Elias laughed. Peter let him eat half a bun on the walk home and made him swear not to testify against him.

That evening he spread the pieces on newspaper at the kitchen table. Lena was upstairs putting away washing. Peter had gone to find a tin of glue and a small drill from the shed. The boat looked worse in the light of the kitchen. Its white cabin had gone grey along one edge where Elias had tried to wipe off some dust with a wet thumb.

Peter came back carrying a shoebox filled with tools, wire, scraps of wood and several screws whose original purposes had long since been forgotten.

"You've got a bit of a job there," he said.

"I can do it."

"I didn't say you couldn't."

They worked without much talking. Peter showed Elias how to use a little clamp to hold the mast together while the glue set. He trimmed a replacement piece for the cabin roof, then handed over the sandpaper and let Elias shape it himself. Twice Elias tried to hurry and Peter made him stop, not to improve the finished boat but because rushing had already cost him too much wood.

"It's not a race," Peter said.

"It needs to be ready tomorrow."

"Does it?"

"Yes."

"Then we'll do what we can."

Lena came in, took in the workbench that had appeared among the plates, and raised her eyebrows.

"Have you decided to open a shipyard in my kitchen?"

"Strictly temporary," Peter said.

"That usually means until Christmas."

"Whose boat is it?" she asked.

"A boy at school."

"That's kind of you, helping him."

The words made Elias put down the brush.

He could have told her then. The kitchen was warm, and his parents were both there, and neither seemed likely to shout. He could have told them about the laugh on Monday, the pencil on Tuesday and the boat on Wednesday. He could have said that the worst thing was not breaking it but carrying every piece home as though a finished repair would erase the rest.

Instead he nodded and picked up the brush again.

The boat was ready near bedtime. Not perfect. The paper cabin had a slightly new-looking roof, and the mast wore a narrow band of dried glue near its base. Peter had added a tiny weight beneath the keel, at Elias's request, so the ROSE would stand without tipping. It made her more stable on the table. It also meant the hull did not sit quite level when Elias held her up to inspect the paint.

"Do you think he'll like it?" Elias asked.

"I think he'll see you've put work into it."

"But will he like it?"

Peter dried his hands. "That's for him to decide."

At ten past eight he wrapped the boat in a tea towel and laid it in a shoebox. On the lid he wrote DANIEL in careful capital letters. Underneath, after a long hesitation, he wrote SORRY ABOUT YOUR BOAT.

He stared at the words. They seemed both too much and not enough. They admitted damage without saying who had done it. They offered an apology from a person who refused to appear.

He crossed out the sentence, then crossed it out again until the paper began to tear. He took a fresh lid from another shoebox and wrote only DANIEL.

The boat lay on the table between them, repaired and still unmistakably broken once.

In the Upper Registry, Cassian Wren was attempting to establish a precedent.

He expanded the record of Elias Rowan's week. On one page stood the laughter in the classroom. On another, the offered pencil. On a third, the small boat being rebuilt under an ordinary kitchen light.

Cassian selected the third page.

"Voluntary restoration of damaged property," he dictated. "Independent initiative. Sustained practical effort. Evidence of emerging social responsibility."

He paused and added a provisional merit point to a margin that did not technically have space for one.

"What is that?" asked a voice behind him.

Ione Thread stood beside the open shelves, carrying a thin folder bound in grey. As Keeper of Uncounted Memories, she was responsible for ensuring that records contained the small events most likely to be omitted from official summaries. Cassian regarded her department as well intentioned and chronically resistant to useful simplification.

"A developmental indicator," he said.

"It appears to be a point."

"Provisional."

"There are no merit points in the Ledger."

"That is because the system is overdue for modernisation."

"The system is designed not to weigh one kindness against one harm."

"Nobody said anything about weighing."

Ione looked at the single point in the margin. "You've put it in a box marked MERIT."

Cassian crossed out the box. He was beginning to see why some offices encouraged appointment-only visitors.

Ione opened her folder. "Where is the apology?"

"What apology?"

"The boy laughed at the new child. Then he broke the child's boat and hid it. He has repaired the boat. I can find no record of his telling the owner what happened."

"The material damage has been addressed."

"Has the other damage?"

Cassian disliked questions that disguised themselves as observations. "The action demonstrates an encouraging tendency to correct errors."

"It does," Ione said. "Why have you omitted the part he still cannot face?"

Cassian closed the third page.

"I record what can be demonstrated," he said.

"Then record the whole demonstration."

She laid the grey folder beside his chart. On its cover someone had written an unpromising title: CONTEXT NOT CAPTURED BY OUTCOME.

"A restoration is a real kindness," Ione said. "It is not the same thing as asking to be forgiven."

"I'll amend the wording," he said.

"That's a beginning."

The next morning Elias reached school early. He slipped through the classroom before assembly and placed the shoebox on Daniel's desk, under the edge of his reading book. For a moment he considered putting the yellow pencil beside it too, but that seemed like another confession in a language he wasn't ready to speak.

He left the pencil in his own tin.

The corridor outside filled with the noise of children arriving. Elias went to the cloakroom, took off his coat, put it on again, then pretended to be searching for a missing glove. From the open classroom door he could see Daniel come in, set down his bag and stop.

Daniel looked at the box for a long time. He read his name on the lid, glanced around the empty desks and opened it. The ROSE lay inside on its folded tea towel, white cabin catching the morning light. Daniel lifted her with both hands. His thumb touched the new roof, then the join on the mast. He saw the paint repaired around the R.

Then he set it on the desk. It stood firm. Daniel pressed one fingertip gently against the mast and watched the vessel right itself.

At last he gave a small smile, and Elias felt a great wave of relief. It wasn't victory exactly. It was the sense of having escaped something.

Daniel carried the boat to the harbour display and put it in its old place. He stepped back, considered the angle, and turned the bow so the blue name faced the room.

Mrs Pritchard appeared behind him. "There it is! Did someone find your boat?"

Daniel nodded. "Someone fixed it."

"How lovely. Do you know who?"

"No, miss."

Elias was standing close enough to hear every word. He could have crossed the classroom in six steps. He could have admitted the break, the laugh, and the fact that a borrowed pencil had been kinder than anything he had managed all week. The boat was fixed. Daniel might still have been angry. Mrs Pritchard might have made him apologise in front of everyone. None of those things would have changed the little vessel on the table.

But the six steps seemed further than the distance between Saltmere's harbour walls.

He stayed where he was.

Daniel ran a finger lightly along the hull, protecting the delicate new mast as he lifted the ROSE from the table once more. He cradled it against his jumper and walked to the window to see how the red cabin looked in daylight.

From behind the classroom door, Elias watched him retrieve what had been lost, and kept his own hands out of sight.