Text

CHAPTER THREE / 2004

The Road Not Taken

By half past seven, the water had reached the second step of Mrs Vale's cottage, and Elias Rowan was trying to keep the rain off his interview portfolio.

He had bought the folder with money from three Saturdays unloading fish crates and spent two evenings arranging it. Inside were school certificates, a teacher's recommendation, a tidal-gate design and a typed statement explaining why he wanted to study engineering at Calder University. Every sheet had its own clear sleeve. The tabs had been cut with a ruler.

If the panel asked him about coastal resilience, he had an answer. If they asked why the drawing showed an additional channel rather than a taller wall, he had an even better one. His father had inspected the drawing twice and suggested making the channel wide enough for something other than a pencil to pass through.

The only question Elias had not prepared for was why the tide had reached Mrs Vale's doorstep in a storm the radio had described, with an irritating air of moderation, as unsettled weather.

Saltmere's low quay was doing its usual winter impersonation of a canal. Water came up through the drains in brown circles. Wind pushed rain beneath doorframes and set a row of wheelie bins drifting along the gutter. Higher up, the shops stood dry. Down here, cottages pressed against the harbour wall, and everyone watched the steps.

Elias stood under the closed chandlery's awning and checked his watch. Seven thirty-four. His bus left at seven forty-eight, connecting with the nine o'clock train to Calder. The interview began at eleven fifteen. If all went to plan, he would arrive with twenty-seven minutes to spare.

He liked having twenty-seven minutes to spare. Twenty-seven was enough time to find a lavatory, inspect his tie and recover from any unforeseen unpleasantness. It was not so much time that the panel might conclude he had nowhere better to be.

Across the street, a door opened.

"Elias!"

Mrs Vale stood in her doorway with one hand on the jamb and the other holding a cardigan closed over her nightdress. Narrow and loud-voiced, she grew nasturtiums in biscuit tins each summer and complained that the flowers had more sense than the council each winter.

"Morning, Mrs Vale."

"Is it?"

She pointed at the water. A wave broke somewhere beyond the wall, and the brown surface on her steps shivered.

"I've got things downstairs," she said. "Albums and my husband's old harbour papers. Would you help me get them up? The bottom drawer's already wet."

Elias looked at his watch again. This was not a negotiation with time so much as a demand that time explain itself.

Mrs Vale was not a stranger. When he was little, she had kept a jar of boiled sweets behind the clock and pretended to be surprised whenever children discovered it. Once, after Elias fell from his bicycle outside her garden, she had brought him inside and removed three tiny stones from his palm with tweezers. He remembered objecting that he could have done it himself. She had told him that he probably could, but was welcome to sit still for a minute. She had said the same thing about his father, who had arrived with a puncture-repair kit before anyone had asked for one.

Now she looked past him to the road, not at his folder. One of the nasturtium tins had overturned on the step, the winter soil spilling into the brown water. Her hand stayed on the doorframe. He noticed, and calculated the journey to the bus stop again.

"I've got an interview."

"At the university? Your mum told me."

"I have to catch the bus."

"You needn't stay long."

Through the doorway he saw darkening curtains and a cardboard box beginning to drink water from the floor. A pale rounded stone held the door open, useless now against the weather pushing inside.

"I'll come back," he said. "After I've caught my bus."

Mrs Vale blinked. "You'll be on the bus then, won't you?"

"I mean when I get back. This afternoon."

She looked over her shoulder. "It'll be a bit late for the photographs."

"Can you put them on the table?"

"I could if the table wasn't already full."

He nearly said that she ought to have moved them yesterday. The forecast had been clear enough about rain. But the sentence formed in his mind with his father's voice attached to its ending, and he kept it to himself.

"I'm sorry. It's important."

"Of course it is, love." She stepped back into the dim room. "You go."

The kindness of her answer made leaving harder for a moment. Then the wind pushed a sheet of rain along the road, and Elias brought the portfolio against his chest and went.

At the corner he looked back. Mrs Vale had not shut the door. She was bending over the box, trying to get both arms around it. For one disagreeable second he imagined himself returning, lifting it, perhaps helping with two or three more, and arriving at the stop just in time to see the rear lights of the bus.

He turned uphill.

The pavement was slick. His shoes were new, bought after his mother rejected six pairs for looking too much like something worn by estate agents. She had ironed his shirt while he recited interview questions, then asked whether he might take the bins out before solving the welfare of the entire species.

At the top of Quay Street he saw five people at the bus shelter and felt a rush of relief. It was seven forty-two. He was early. His plan had survived its first encounter with the world.

A man in a yellow jacket emerged from the junction and began moving the temporary road barrier across the lane.

"Bus isn't coming," the man told them.

There was a pause in which everyone waited for him to withdraw the remark.

"What do you mean?" Elias asked.

"I mean what I said. Bridge Road's flooded. Police have closed the bottom crossing. Service is turning back at the depot."

"But this is the station bus."

"Well, it isn't the station bus today, is it?"

"How long will the road be closed?"

The man looked at the sky, then at the barrier. "I could ask the rain to stop. Can't promise it'll listen."

An older woman laughed. Elias did not. He pulled the paper timetable from his pocket and opened it, shielding it with his folder. At seven forty-eight a neat black number stood beside SALTMERE QUAY. Further down the page, other numbers waited with the absolute indifference of printed things.

"There's a bus from the market square," he said.

"Not over Bridge Road there isn't."

"What about the bypass?"

"You could try walking."

The bypass was too far. The two taxi firms were occupied. He called one and heard a recording; the other told him no driver would come down to the quay. He thanked the dispatcher so stiffly that she apologised for the weather as if she had ordered it.

He rang the university and, after two transfers, reached someone who advised sending an email to admissions. Elias explained he was standing in the rain, miles from a computer, and the interview was that morning. The voice suggested keeping the office informed of changes to his travel arrangements.

"They haven't changed," he said. "They've stopped."

At eight twelve he was still beneath the shelter. He had missed the only connection that would get him to Calder on time. Even if someone drove him to the station, the railway line beyond it was being inspected after the storm. A man with a folded newspaper told him so. Elias did not believe him until a conductor walking home confirmed it.

The other stranded passengers had dispersed. Elias remained on the wooden bench, with his portfolio standing upright on his shoes and his coat wrapped round it. Rain ran off the roof in a steady cord, striking the pavement beside his left foot.

A group of sixth-formers in dark coats came up from the market carrying a rolled tarpaulin between them. Two were laughing about the rain. They turned down Quay Street without hesitation, apparently going wherever someone had asked them to go. Elias watched until their heads disappeared behind the roofs.

He could follow them. There was nothing stopping him now except the certainty that the decision would feel worse once he had made it. A second failure could be hidden inside the first: he could be late to the interview because the road was closed, and late to help because he had waited for a bus that never came. No one at Calder would know what he did next. No one in Saltmere would have to know how long it took him.

He thought about Mrs Vale's box.

It was probably wet by now. She would find a neighbour, or the council would send someone, or the tide would fall before it did any real damage. There were several reasonable explanations for why he could not be expected to help. Each of them was more attractive than the thought of walking back down Quay Street and discovering that he had been wrong.

At eight twenty-seven, with no interview to attend and no bus to catch, he was still sitting there.

He told himself that he needed a moment to think.

The moment became nineteen minutes.

When he finally stood, his legs were stiff. He walked back by the market so nobody from the bus shelter would see him change direction. He knew the precaution was absurd and resented having taken it.

Downhill, the water had become a narrow current along the gutter, carrying leaves and a plastic bottle. A cyclist pushed his bicycle through it. At the quay, two men lifted sandbags from a van.

Mrs Vale's door stood open again, though the water had climbed above the third step. The cardboard box was no longer visible from outside.

Elias stopped beneath the awning of the chandlery. He could reach the cottage in less than a minute. He knew that because he had measured the distance with his eyes as he approached, calculating which portions of the pavement remained above the water. Yet he did not move.

Someone shouted from the quay.

"Keep back from that drain!"

A man with an aluminium ladder emerged from the quay. Elias recognised Farid Dey, a dockworker who had helped Peter with a winch. Farid's son Malik had been at school below Elias, asking persistent questions about pumps, drainage and why the council flood map ended just before his street.

Farid placed the ladder against Mrs Vale's upstairs windowsill and tested its feet on the stones. His first attempt slid sideways. He lifted it, found a firmer position and had one of the men with sandbags hold the base.

"Mrs Vale!" he called. "I'm coming in from above. Keep your hands away from that front door."

She appeared at the upstairs window, her face small and pale behind the glass.

"I can manage," she said.

"That's what I'm afraid of. Open the sash, please."

"You can't climb that in this weather."

"I can if you stop negotiating with me about it."

The man holding the ladder braced himself. Farid climbed, one rung at a time, his boots making a hollow metallic sound. At the window he paused to make sure Mrs Vale had moved clear, then swung himself inside with an awkwardness that made Elias wince. He disappeared.

Elias left the awning. Water gurgled in the drain beside the cottage, and the front door banged against something inside. Mrs Vale had been right about the danger. She had also been right that his interview would have been less use to the photographs than a pair of hands.

From the upstairs window, Farid called down.

From somewhere inside the cottage Mrs Vale called out about a little tin beneath the sideboard. Farid's answer came back indistinct, followed by the sound of a chair scraping. Elias recognised the tone from his father's work: a person attempting to be reassuring while carrying something heavy and wishing the other person would stay put.

He knew that the water was not deep enough to sweep an adult off his feet on the upper pavement. It was the surfaces under the water that mattered: hidden steps, loose flagstones, the open mouth of the drain. He knew because he had drawn their equivalent on paper. Farid knew because he had watched a man's boot disappear into the wrong gap a winter earlier and helped pull him out.

"Can one of you take a box?"

One of the sandbag men went up three rungs and received a cardboard archive box wrapped in a sheet. He carried it down, holding it away from his jacket. Another box followed. Then a flat case containing photographs behind glass.

Elias started towards them, but stopped when the man with the first box slipped on the paving. The man recovered, swore quietly, and kept his grip. There was still a chance of an accident, and Elias understood with a painful clarity that he did not want the person responsible for it to be himself.

He remained on the dry side of the water, holding the portfolio beneath his coat.

Farid leaned through the window again. "The bottom drawers are going. I need to get one more trunk up from the sitting room. Tell the lads not to come in through the front."

Farid disappeared inside. The others waited while furniture scraped upstairs and something heavy struck a stair tread. Mrs Vale's voice came faintly through the window.

Then Farid reappeared with a wooden case balanced against his shoulder. His cap had fallen off, and rain had flattened his grey hair.

"Right," he said. "That's the one."

The case was awkward. The man on the ladder received it with both hands and had to turn sideways to clear the metal frame. For an instant its lower corner dipped. A bundle of photographs slid towards the opening, and Elias saw the pale face of a child beneath a pane of cracked glass.

He took a step forward. The man steadied the case and brought it safely down.

It was already over. Elias had moved when there was nothing left to prevent.

Farid climbed down, less confidently than he had gone up. His trousers were soaked above the knee and harbour mud ran down one sleeve. At the bottom he stood breathing hard.

"She's all right," he said. "Bit shaken. Won't come away from the place, but she's up out of the water."

"You should get her out," Elias said.

Farid turned and looked at him. "You offering?"

"I mean, if the water keeps rising."

"It might. We don't know yet." Farid rubbed his hands together for warmth. "Are you Peter Rowan's lad?"

"Yes. Elias."

"You were at school with our Malik."

"I know."

"He'd have come down himself, but he's helping at the pump house. He's forever telling people where water ought to go. Now he's having to find out."

Elias glanced at the quay. Someone had opened the door to the old net store on the higher side of the road and was laying a tarpaulin over its workbench.

"Do those need to go inside?" he asked.

Farid followed his gaze. "If you'd give us a hand, that would be useful. The worst of it is up the ladder already. Don't try taking anything through the water. Stay on the paving."

At last there was an instruction with a beginning, an end and a reasonable prospect of success. Elias gave his portfolio to the man from the van, asking him twice to keep it dry, then picked up a box of harbour records.

The box held damp harbour ledgers, photographs in brown envelopes, a brass rule and letters tied with ribbon. Elias carried it to the net store and laid the contents out so the paper could dry.

He fetched more boxes, spread newspapers and began listing what had been saved. Dates, subjects and damage could be organised. The work suited him. He could be useful without wondering whether somebody might be hurt by his next decision.

"You want to stop writing and put those photographs flat," Farid told him, pointing at Elias's new list.

"I'm recording what we've got."

"Aye, and while you're recording it they're curling up."

Elias put down the pencil.

Mrs Vale came into the net store a little after ten, escorted along the higher pavement by one of the sandbag men. She had changed into dry shoes and a coat much too large for her. Her hair had escaped its pins. She looked at the things arranged along the workbench and stopped with one hand against her mouth.

"My goodness," she said. "Look at all that."

"Some are damp," Elias told her. "But if we keep them apart, they ought to be all right."

"You've done all this?"

"We've been sorting them."

She reached out and touched the edge of a photograph, not the image itself. Her fingers shook.

"These were my husband's," she said. "He kept records of the boats. Everyone said he was daft to bother because the harbour office had its own, but he knew their books went missing whenever someone moved a cupboard."

Mrs Vale lifted a ledger by its dry spine. Each page contained dates, weather notes and the names of boats coming in and out of the harbour. Beside some names a second hand had added remarks: late because of engine trouble; borrowed rope returned; no catch but all crew safe. Those details were not required by the harbour office. She ran a finger down the margins as though the writing itself might bring the voices back.

"He always put in the people," she said. "I used to tell him that was why it took so long. He'd be here until supper trying to remember who'd lent a coat to whom. Said a boat wasn't much of a story if you left the men out of it."

Elias glanced at the papers he had sorted by date. He had separated the pages very efficiently. He had not read the margins.

"He was probably right," Elias said.

"He generally was about cupboards. Less so about most other things."

Farid laughed. He had found a kettle in the net store and was trying to persuade it to produce four cups of tea from two tea bags and what remained of a packet of milk.

Mrs Vale took Elias's hand. Her palm felt papery and cold.

"Thank you for coming back," she said. "I knew you were meant to be somewhere important. You came when it mattered."

Elias felt the familiar moment opening before him. It was the same shape as the space beside Daniel's desk nine years earlier, when six steps would have been enough to tell the truth about a broken boat.

He could tell her about the bench, the dry folder, the long delay before he returned. He could explain that Farid and the others had done the dangerous work. He could say he had helped only when it was safe.

Mrs Vale squeezed his hand.

"Your father will be proud of you."

Elias said, "I hope the photographs dry."

It was not quite an answer, and she accepted it anyway.

Farid brought tea in mismatched mugs, including one with a chipped rim. Mrs Vale insisted the climbers should drink first. Farid told her he'd used worse cups for forty years. Soon they were discussing tide gates and which councillor would come to be photographed beside a sandbag once the weather improved.

He knew he could correct her. He knew she would probably still thank him.

But being thanked felt so much better than being understood that he let the story stand.

Peter found him after lunch, sorting photographs at the net store. His father had come from the harbour with his waterproofs open and his face red from the cold. A coil of rope lay in the van and hot engine oil scented the air.

"Your mum said you'd be at Calder," Peter said.

"The road closed. I rang them."

"Did you get through?"

"Sort of. They're expecting an email."

Peter nodded, as though that was a problem with several ordinary solutions. "We'll write one when we get home."

"They'll just give the place to someone else."

"Maybe. Maybe they'll give you another date."

"They won't. Not for an interview like this."

"Have they said that?"

Elias looked down. "No."

Peter greeted Mrs Vale and offered to find someone for her flooded boiler, then returned to Elias. His eyes travelled over the drying papers.

"Farid says you helped get her things out."

"Yes."

"Good of you."

Elias began straightening the photographs. "They were going to get ruined."

"Most things do if you leave them in water."

Peter looked at Elias's trousers and shoes. Two narrow smears of brown marked his cuffs where the cardboard had brushed them. His knees and new leather shoes were clean. Peter's own trousers were muddy above the boots.

"You didn't have to go into the water?" Peter asked.

"Not really. Farid had done the difficult bit before I started helping."

His father looked up. "Before you started helping?"

"I went to the bus stop first."

"I see."

"I was going to help after the interview," he said. "But the bus was cancelled. And I couldn't know the road would close."

"No," Peter said. "You couldn't."

"So I came back."

"You did."

Peter looked across at Mrs Vale, who was smiling at a photograph of someone she recognised.

Elias knew his father's hands. He had watched them tying knots, repairing hinges and putting the little model boat back together after Elias broke it years ago. They were the sort of hands people asked for when something had gone wrong. His own hands had become good at ruler marks, algebra and keeping important papers untouched. It was not that he disliked work. He disliked the point at which work might fail while other people could see him doing it.

Peter took his hand away from the table. There was mud caught beneath his thumbnail, and he seemed not to notice it.

"Helping late is still helping," he said.

Elias waited for the rest. His father did not supply it. The kettle hissed beside them. Outside, Farid called for someone to take the road barrier out of the way of a council truck.

"But I could have helped earlier," Elias said.

Peter looked at him for a long moment. Not angrily. The look was worse than anger because it left Elias free to decide what he meant.

"Aye," he said. "You probably could have."

"It wouldn't have changed the bus."

"No."

"Or the interview."

"Maybe not."

Elias had wanted his father to explain that no sensible person could sacrifice his future for old papers. That the photographs survived should have proved his decision correct. Instead Peter looked tired, the lines beside his mouth deeper than Elias remembered.

"You know," Peter said, "I don't think that's the bit you're asking about."

Elias stared at the table. His father picked up an empty tea mug, took it to the sink and rinsed it. It was the kind of unnecessary small job Peter did when a conversation had become too complicated for fixing.

"We'll send that email," Peter said. "Get your mum to read it before I do. She'll stop you writing six pages about the road closure."

"I've only prepared three."

Peter gave him a sideways look. "Of course you have."

It almost made Elias laugh.

They drove past the sea wall, holding the town and the water in an uneasy arrangement. Highway workers were lifting a branch from a drain, Farid's ladder was strapped to a dock van, and the flooded cottages looked small beneath the sky.

At home Lena had found the admissions office number. She listened while Elias described the bridge, the cancelled bus and the closed railway. He told her about helping Mrs Vale and Farid's ladder, but not the bench under the bus shelter or the long pause beneath the chandlery awning.

"You did a good thing," Lena said.

He should have felt better. Instead he became annoyed with her for believing him.

The email took forty-three minutes to write. Peter read it and asked why it contained the phrase adverse logistical conditions. Lena crossed out the phrase and replaced it with flooding. She deleted a paragraph explaining the reliability of the printed bus timetable, then another setting out the probability of road closures. At last she pressed the mouse into Elias's hand.

"They need to know you couldn't get there," she said. "Not that you can win an argument with a bus."

He sent the message. The screen displayed a small confirmation, and there was nothing else he could do.

That afternoon Elias tried to improve his harbour drawing. The additional channel had seemed elegant. Now he saw the people on the quay standing outside flooded homes. He drew a second route to higher ground, then erased it because the slope was wrong.

When he stood to stretch, he found a pale smear of dried harbour silt on his left cuff. He rubbed at it with his thumb until the cloth went shiny. It remained visible. Far from Saltmere, in the Upper Registry, Cassian Wren was reviewing the consequences of a missed interview.

Cassian had arranged three sheets: academic prospects, road closure, and delayed help with a neighbour's records. He highlighted the closure in yellow. Weather, in his view, was a poor educational variable.

"An avoidable scheduling problem," he announced.

Ione Thread was studying a different part of the file. "The road flooded."

"Precisely. A robust contingency plan would have anticipated this."

"Would it have prevented the road flooding?"

"No. It would have prevented the missed appointment."

"You cannot establish that from the record."

"There were alternative routes."

"All closed."

Cassian turned the page. "Some institution ought to have provided a telephone interview."

"Then write to the institution."

"I am not allowed to."

"No."

He considered whether the delay counted as lost opportunity or as a test of adaptability. The latter sounded more constructive at a performance hearing.

Ione looked at the third sheet. "And the neighbour?"

"Helped. Belongings salvaged. Positive community outcome."

"By whom?"

"Several people."

"Who went inside?"

"A dockworker."

"Who stood outside?"

Cassian made a face. "We cannot log every moment of inaction as a separate event. There would be no room for the events themselves."

"There was room," Ione said. "For the boy, I mean. He had time to stand there."

"I will add a note," he said at last.

He selected a narrow margin beside the timetable and wrote: SUBJECT EXPERIENCED DISRUPTION, FOLLOWED BY PROSOCIAL RECOVERY.

Ione read it. "He'll remember something different."

"He won't remember this report."

"I wasn't speaking about the report."

Cassian put down his pen. Through the high windows of the Registry, a colourless light fell upon the abandoned forms. He had no way of changing anything in Saltmere, and for once the impossibility irritated him less than the suspicion that his own account had overlooked something obvious. That night he dreamed briefly of the flooded cottage, though in the dream the water was perfectly still. He stood on the bottom step with an open folder in his hands. The pages remained dry, but the ink had vanished from every one. He woke before anything else happened and lay listening to the heating pipes. By morning the dream had become difficult to picture. He remembered only how relieved he had been that the folder was not ruined.

The next morning Elias returned to Mrs Vale's cottage. Silt coated the steps and a dark tide mark crossed the lower walls. The council had tested the electrics; someone was examining the boiler. Inside smelled of damp plaster and tea.

He brought the box of photographs from the net store. Mrs Vale sat at the table, laying pictures on a cloth and deciding which mounts could be saved.

"There you are," she said. "Come and tell me which way round this one goes."

Three men stood beside a fishing boat, the sea white behind them. One man's hand rested on a child's shoulder. The child in a knitted hat stared at the camera, solemn as though resisting a joke.

"That way," Elias said, turning the mount.

"So it is. I ought to get these sorted before I forget which is which."

On the table beside her lay several envelopes. One was thick and cream-coloured, addressed in Mrs Vale's careful hand to her grandson, Tom Vale. The flap had not been sealed. A corner of another photograph protruded beneath it, showing the face of a boy beside an older man in a dark coat.

Mrs Vale noticed his glance. "I'm putting a few aside for Tom," she said. "He'll want them one day."

Elias could have asked about the boy, the man, or why the pictures mattered enough to risk retrieving them from the flood. He had no bus to catch or interview waiting now.

Instead he lifted the dry box from the table and carried it upstairs, where he could put everything in the right place.

When he came down, the envelope was still open. He saw the face in the photograph once more and did not ask whose it was.