Text

CHAPTER FOUR / 2010

A Better Prediction

"Can a model be wrong and still be useful?"

Elias Rowan had prepared for questions about coastal erosion, uncertainty intervals and why he wanted to work for Northbank Resilience instead of a larger firm with a more expensive sign. He had prepared an explanation for the patchwork of Saturday jobs that had helped pay for his studies. He had even prepared an answer to the question of what he considered his greatest weakness, though it involved describing impatience as an excess of curiosity and made him feel faintly fraudulent.

He had not prepared for this.

The woman opposite him wore a dark green jacket and had the expression of someone who had been promised a short meeting and given a long one. Her name was Helen Wainwright. She had been introduced as director of delivery, which Elias understood to mean that if a computer produced the right answer and the council disliked it, she was the person expected to make the council like it.

"It depends what you mean by useful," he said.

At the end of the table a man with a red tie made a note. He had already made several notes, all without looking particularly pleased.

"I mean," Helen said, "would you put a prediction in front of a council if you knew it might be wrong?"

"Every prediction might be wrong. Otherwise it wouldn't be a prediction. It would be a record."

The man in the red tie stopped writing.

"So you would?" Helen asked.

"If the uncertainty were visible, yes. If the assumptions were defensible. And if we knew what decision the prediction was supposed to help somebody make."

"What if they don't want the uncertainty?"

"Then they shouldn't have asked a modeller."

He heard himself say it and wondered whether he had just lost the job.

A third interviewer, a younger woman who had introduced herself as Priya Shah, lowered her pen to the table to conceal a smile. Helen did not smile. She tapped the corner of a printout with one finger.

"Suppose we've got enough money to protect two of six coastal communities. All six are exposed. All six have residents who believe they should be first. Where do you start?"

"With the data. Population, property, infrastructure, probability of failure, expected losses. Then we establish what the available intervention can actually achieve."

"And the other four?"

"They don't stop existing because the calculation doesn't favour them."

Priya looked up properly this time.

"That's an elegant answer," Helen said. "Not a very practical one."

Elias felt the interview moving away from him. It was a familiar sensation. Six years earlier a bus had failed to arrive, a railway line had closed, and his first attempt to impress Calder University had ended beneath a shelter while he argued privately with the timetable. He had eventually been offered a second interview. Then a place. Then a degree. None of it had cured the part of him that believed one unforeseen difficulty could pull the floor out from beneath a life.

"I mean we have to distinguish between reducing harm and defending a decision," he said. "If two communities can be protected, we ought to explain why those two. We ought to tell the others what we've assumed, where we're uncertain, and what a different budget might change. There are decisions we can't make painless. We can at least make them honest."

The red-tied man leaned forward. "Councillors don't pay us to make speeches about honesty."

"No," Elias said. "They pay you to reduce exposure."

"To optimise it," the man corrected.

Elias glanced at the words on the presentation screen behind them: PRIORITISATION FOR CONSTRAINED CAPITAL ENVIRONMENTS. The title had occupied nearly an entire slide. He could feel himself approaching the point in an interview where an intelligent answer gave way to the answer that got you hired.

"Then our job is optimised ethical exposure," he said.

There was a small silence.

Priya coughed into her hand. The man in the red tie wrote something rapidly. Helen looked at Elias for an extraordinary length of time and then laughed.

"Optimised ethical exposure," she repeated. "Good Lord. Giles, we should put that on a brochure."

"I'd rather we didn't," Elias said.

"Why?"

"I'm not sure it means anything."

This time all three laughed. Elias joined them, relieved, and failed to notice that Giles had underlined the phrase twice.

When the interview ended, Helen shook his hand and said they would be in touch. He rode the lift down twelve floors with a woman carrying a broken umbrella, stepped out into London rain and opened his notebook beneath the shelter of a doorway. The page was full of small observations: questions answered, names to remember, an incorrect figure he had quoted for the third case study. Beside it he wrote the phrase that had made the room laugh, then drew a line through ethical. He couldn't say precisely why.

At half past four his telephone rang.

"Mr Rowan? Helen Wainwright. We've decided to offer you the graduate analyst position."

He said thank you twice, with what he hoped was professional restraint. Then he put the telephone away, brought it out again, and called his mother.

"Well?" Lena answered.

"They've offered it."

"Good. Your father owes me ten pounds."

"Why?"

"He said you'd hear tomorrow. I said today."

"You were betting on my interview?"

"On the people interviewing you, darling. I knew you'd do your part."

He stood in the rain smiling at a wall. Across the street, a young man hurried towards a taxi with a laptop held above his head to protect it from the weather.

"You sound pleased," Lena said.

"I am."

"Then be pleased. You can worry about it on Monday."

The invitation was appealing. Elias opened his notebook anyway and wrote Monday under the crossed-out phrase.

Northbank Resilience occupied three floors of a converted insurance building near the river. Its reception featured a photograph of a storm surge striking a sea defence, so beautifully lit that Elias initially wondered whether the photographer had been allowed to enjoy the disaster. Beneath it a brass plaque announced that Northbank was committed to building safer futures.

On his first morning he was issued a building pass, two passwords and a chair whose height adjustment operated only when someone stood on it. A woman in human resources took him through a presentation about excellence, innovation and wellbeing. Every photograph showed people standing in groups of four, smiling as though someone had just revealed the result of an exam they had all passed.

"Any questions?" she asked.

"Who should I tell about the chair?"

"Facilities."

"Is that on this floor?"

"They've outsourced it."

He made a note.

Priya Shah found him at eleven with a mug of tea and a folder so thick that its elastic band had begun to fray.

"Come on," she said. "I'll show you what we actually do."

She had studied statistics, preferred tea without milk and possessed a way of reading a spreadsheet that made Elias feel she could hear it lying. At the end of the open-plan office, she showed him a wall map of the east coast covered in coloured pins. Red marked urgent investigation. Amber marked projects awaiting further evidence. Green marked schemes approved or considered acceptable within existing provision. The blue pins were fewer. They looked strangely serene among the other colours.

"Blue?" Elias asked.

"It depends which project you're looking at. Usually outside the present funding comparison. Sometimes a dataset isn't complete enough for ranking. Don't confuse it with safe."

"Why use blue?"

"A former director said grey made the presentation depressing."

"And blue doesn't?"

"Apparently it makes him think of holiday brochures."

Priya led him past desks piled with survey drawings and into a room where a projector displayed a table of flood-defence proposals. The first column contained council names. The second contained schemes. The remaining columns filled the screen with predicted costs, probabilities, confidence ranges, population counts and monetary estimates of avoided damage.

"The councils have less than they want to spend," Priya said. "Often a good deal less. We help them decide what to submit, what to investigate and what to put off. That's the polite description."

"What's the impolite one?"

"We make disappointment legible."

She clicked a cell, and the rankings changed.

"A third of the work is gathering decent evidence. Another third is getting it into a form that can be compared without doing too much violence to the original."

"And the last third?"

"Explaining to people why the thing they've been waiting for hasn't happened."

He studied the table. It was the most absorbing thing he had seen in months. At Calder he had liked theoretical problems until they stopped feeling like problems at all and became elegant exercises. Here, an adjustment to a drainage estimate could change which wall got repaired. He could build something without ever laying a brick.

"It matters," he said.

"Yes," Priya replied. "That's what makes it awkward."

For three weeks he worked late without being asked. He corrected references, checked survey assumptions against historical tides and discovered that a decimal place could survive four rounds of review because everyone presumed someone else had checked it. One Friday he found a transposed number in a calculation for a pumping station. The scheme had appeared too expensive by nearly half a million pounds. When he corrected it, the project climbed six places.

Priya read his note, then read it again.

"Good catch," she said. "Send it to me with the source files."

He did, and for an hour walked around with the pleasant sensation of having made the world fractionally more reliable. Then Priya returned.

"We found another survey that changes the foundation estimate. It's still expensive."

"But the error was real."

"Of course. Fixing it was worth doing. It just wasn't the whole answer."

He knew that. He had always known that. Yet he was disappointed, and the disappointment bothered him more than the result.

At the end of his first month Helen called him to her office. She asked him to sit and pushed a printed presentation across the desk. The title was EVIDENCE-LED INVESTMENT: FROM COMPLEXITY TO CLARITY.

Halfway through, in a blue box beside an aerial photograph of a coastline, Elias saw the words OPTIMISED ETHICAL EXPOSURE.

"That's from the interview," he said.

"It tested very well with the delivery team."

"It doesn't have a defined meaning."

"It's a proposition."

"Of what?"

"Of confidence, Elias. People need to know we can make sense of difficult choices."

He looked at the box. The phrase had acquired a small copyright mark and a line of explanatory text that explained nothing.

"Will you be using it with councils?"

"Not the technical officers. Senior decision-makers. We have to speak their language too."

She gave him the presentation to keep. On the journey home he put it in his bag between the cleaner specification sheets. He did not throw it away.

The first time he saw Nadia Bell, she was arguing with a railway announcement.

"We regret the inconvenience," said the recorded voice.

"No, you don't," Nadia replied.

Elias was in the carriage seat opposite, attempting to finish a report on his laptop. The train had been standing outside a station for thirty-seven minutes. A failed signal had apparently required every railway employee within fifty miles to consult a colleague before deciding what to do. It was early July. The windows were too warm, the drinks trolley had run out of water, and someone further down the carriage was eating an egg sandwich with a devotion Elias found difficult to admire.

"I doubt it can hear you," he said.

"That's part of its problem."

She had a canvas bag at her feet and a spiral notebook open on her lap. The bag was full of loose papers, an apple and a cardigan. A pen protruded from her hair. Her face had that lively, alert expression some people wore when they found the world interesting even when it was being particularly tiresome.

"You work for the railway?" she asked.

"No. Why?"

"You have the look of a man who wants to defend the announcement."

"It's probably automated from a standard incident code."

"Worse. You do want to defend it."

"I was only explaining."

"I know. It's a very popular hobby."

He went back to his screen. The carriage gave a small hopeful lurch and stopped again. He glanced up. She was writing something in a notebook, pressing hard enough to mark the page beneath.

"What does it say?" he asked.

"The announcement?"

"Your notebook."

"Things I'm supposed to know before somebody trusts me in their house."

She turned it over, not secretively but to stop the pages folding. On the cover were the words COMMUNITY NURSING PLACEMENT, written in uneven capitals.

"You're a nurse?"

"Trainee. If I were fully qualified I'd be allowed to look more exhausted."

She had been on a training day in London and was heading back towards Saltmere, where she was spending a placement with the district nursing team. She lived in a rented room above a hairdresser's and had learned that the quickest way to be invited to someone's home was to mention she could change a dressing, while the quickest way to be offered tea was to say she had already eaten.

"And you?" she asked.

"Flood risk."

"As a hobby?"

"Professionally."

"I suppose somebody has to."

He told her about Northbank. He expected his account of coastal exposure, limited funds and predictive modelling to produce the polite nod that usually appeared at this point in a conversation. Instead she asked how they chose which neighbourhoods got the money.

"We compare probable losses against the cost and benefit of intervention," he said. "There are other factors, of course."

"Like what?"

"How many people are exposed, the effect on transport, hospitals, public facilities. The reliability of the evidence."

"And what if you've got the wrong number of people?"

"Then we correct it."

"How do you know?"

"Know what?"

"That you've got the wrong number."

"We cross-check the census, property records, council figures."

"Do the council figures know who can't get out of bed without two people helping?"

"That sort of detail belongs in an emergency response plan."

"I'm not asking whose folder it goes in. I'm asking whether anybody knows."

He closed a spreadsheet window without saving it and opened the one behind. He was conscious that she had asked an obvious question and that he had answered a different one.

"The model can't hold every piece of information about everyone," he said.

"Of course not. Nor can my little notebook. If I wrote down everything about Mrs Ellery on Church Street, I'd need a wheelbarrow."

"Then how do you decide what's relevant?"

"I ask her. And sometimes she tells me something I didn't think to ask."

"That isn't a method you can scale across sixty thousand properties."

"No. I'm not proposing sixty thousand cups of tea. I'm just saying the people who aren't in the calculation are still there when you finish it."

Elias looked out at the stationary hedgerow. He could see the sense in what she meant. He could also see six impossible ways of putting it into practice, and his mind had begun arranging them into categories before she finished speaking.

"You could incorporate vulnerability weighting," he said.

"You could."

"If the data were available."

"Yes."

"You sound unconvinced."

"I sound hungry. Is that egg sandwich getting stronger or is it just me?"

He laughed. It surprised him. He had been defending himself for twenty minutes without feeling attacked, and now the entire argument had been interrupted by a sandwich.

The train moved. Everyone in the carriage looked up with the grateful disbelief usually reserved for improbable good news. The announcement congratulated itself on the resumption of service. Nadia offered Elias half an apple, which he refused until she pointed out that no one was asking him to undertake a formal procurement process.

At the next station, the train stopped for good.

The conductor explained that an electrical problem had made the route ahead unavailable and that passengers would be transferred to onward services from the opposite platform. He did not appear pleased with the explanation himself. People stood, gathered coats and bags, and began pressing towards the doors. Elias folded his laptop and checked the timetable app on his telephone. Its display still showed the train arriving in Saltmere forty-one minutes earlier.

"That's hopeless," he said.

"So are we staying here?" Nadia asked.

"No, we have to cross the bridge. There's a connection on the other side."

He stepped onto the platform and saw the sign above the lift: OUT OF ORDER.

A woman in a wheelchair was waiting beside it, a small overnight bag balanced on her knees. She wore a yellow scarf and an expression of exhausted patience. A teenage boy stood nearby with her shopping bag, looking between the stairs and the lift as though one might change its mind.

"Excuse me," the woman called to a member of staff. "They told me I'd be able to get across here."

The staff member was already answering someone else. He pointed towards the footbridge, then saw the wheelchair and lowered his arm.

"I'll need to ask the supervisor."

"You asked the supervisor last time," she said.

"I wasn't here last time, madam."

"Neither was my supper. That's rather the point."

The staff member hurried away.

Elias looked at the lift, then at the station map. A blue wheelchair symbol appeared beside each platform, with a dotted line connecting them. There was no warning on the app. He opened the service information page and found a notice about planned engineering work the following Sunday, nothing about the broken lift.

"That shouldn't be showing as accessible," he said.

Nadia had already gone over to the woman.

"Where are you trying to get to?" she asked.

"Saltmere. And I'd quite like to arrive before my daughter thinks I've eloped."

"I'm going there too. I'm Nadia."

"Joan Kaye. This is my grandson, Ellis. He's doing a very good impression of a hatstand."

The boy lifted the shopping bag. "I'm holding all your stuff, Gran."

"Yes, love. And doing it beautifully."

Nadia asked whether Joan wanted her to find a member of staff. Joan said she did, provided it was someone who could make a decision rather than send her to an office which sent her to another office. Nadia went to the station entrance. Elias followed, carrying his laptop case.

"The accessibility data is wrong," he said. "It's linked to a static station record, not live lift status. If they connected the fault log to the timetable app, it could reroute passengers automatically. I could probably write something that would do it."

"Could you?"

"It's not very complicated."

"How long?"

"To prototype? A weekend, maybe."

"Excellent. Would it help Joan tonight?"

"Obviously not tonight."

"Then let's find someone with a key."

At the ticket office a clerk directed them to the platform supervisor, who directed them to a control room. Nadia refused to return to the platform without an answer. She was not rude. Elias thought rudeness might have been more economical. She asked for the name of the person responsible for accessible onward transport, wrote it down, and requested that the person be called. When the supervisor suggested they could simply wait for the lift engineer, she asked whether anyone knew when the engineer would arrive.

"We've logged the fault," he said.

"Yes," Nadia replied. "But Joan doesn't live in the fault log."

After a long conversation involving two telephones and three departments, a staff member appeared with the key to a level service gate and confirmed that accessible transport could be arranged on the station side of the tracks. The alternative route required a member of staff to escort the group along the outside perimeter. It was farther than the bridge but did not involve stairs, and no one had thought to mention it until Nadia asked.

"Is that all right with you?" she asked Joan when they returned.

"It's a bit of a hike. But I prefer a long journey on the ground to a short one in the air."

"Would you like me to take the bag?" Elias asked.

Joan glanced at Ellis. "Ask my grandson. He's been promoted to chief of luggage."

Ellis handed over the shopping bag gratefully. It weighed very nearly as much as Elias's laptop.

They walked by the service road with a railway employee leading the way. Joan set the pace and told them about her daughter, who had been ringing every fifteen minutes, and about her husband, who thought it was possible to improve any meal by adding mustard. Elias listened while carrying the shopping. He noticed that Joan had been waiting far longer than the train's advertised delay. The app had counted the late service but not the hour she had spent trying to get to it.

At the station forecourt an accessible taxi was arranged to take Joan and Ellis onwards. They waited until the driver arrived and Joan had confirmed the destination and fare arrangements with the station staff. She refused Nadia's offer of a bottle of water but accepted a packet of plain biscuits from a vending machine.

"I hope they fix the lift," Elias told her.

"I hope they tell people before they buy a ticket," Joan answered. "That would be a lovely start."

She thanked all of them, including Ellis, who said he hadn't really done anything. Joan advised him never to say that in front of an employer.

When the taxi left, Nadia and Elias were standing beneath a forecourt awning with a ticket inspector, a broken vending machine and no clear idea when the next replacement bus would arrive.

"You were right about the app," she said.

"It won't be any use unless somebody agrees to change the data feed."

"I know. It was still a good idea."

He looked at her. "You didn't seem to think so before."

"I thought it was an excellent idea for Saturday. It just wasn't a very good idea for Thursday evening."

The inspector came over with two handwritten travel authorisations, since the machine had failed to validate their tickets. On Elias's slip he wrote the date, destination and a barely legible signature. Nadia examined the paper.

"Look at that," she said. "A functioning technology. It even works when the signal doesn't."

"You can't automate everything with paper."

"No. But you can hand it to someone."

They boarded a bus half an hour later. Elias kept the travel authorisation in his coat pocket after the inspector said there was no need to surrender it. He could not have explained why.

By the following Tuesday Northbank had received a set of revised funding assumptions from one of its council clients. A proposed grant had been reduced, and several schemes that had been difficult to justify were now impossible to recommend within the available envelope. Giles summoned the analysts to a meeting and asked whether the decision table could be made easier to understand.

"It already has the cost, the expected benefit and the probability ranges," Elias said.

"Exactly," Giles replied. "Too much to understand."

Priya sat very still beside him.

On the screen the projects were arranged in order of estimated return. A scheme protecting a small residential road lay just below the provisional line for further funding consideration. Another, supporting an industrial site and a road interchange, sat comfortably above it. The residential project had a larger uncertainty range. Three households were not represented in the current property register because an old warehouse had been converted to flats without an updated survey reaching the team.

"We need the recommendation to be unambiguous," Giles continued. "Red, amber, green. Something a cabinet member can grasp between a traffic report and the school budget."

"The thresholds aren't physical boundaries," Priya said. "They're choices about where to spend."

"Which is why we need to make a choice."

"We can make one without pretending the difference between 0.79 and 0.82 is the difference between danger and safety."

Giles rubbed his forehead. "Nobody is asking you to pretend. I am asking for a presentation that doesn't require a postgraduate qualification to read."

Elias understood both positions. He had spent his university years trying to make difficult questions clearer. He also knew that a category could remain accurate if its definition were printed beneath it. He raised his hand slightly, then felt ridiculous and put it down.

"What if the colours describe the status of the recommendation," he said, "rather than the level of hazard? Green for funding consideration, amber for more evidence, red for no current approval. With a separate hazard layer."

"There," Giles said. "That makes sense. Can we do it by Friday?"

"We can," Priya said. "Provided the legend stays on every page."

Elias built the revised view. He used conditional formatting so that the colours changed automatically when assumptions were updated. In the technical workbook the categories were accompanied by confidence ranges, source notes and comments explaining what was excluded. In the meeting slides, by the time the charts had been reduced to fit alongside the headings, most of those notes sat in a table at the back.

On Thursday he watched Giles present the result to Helen. Three neatly coloured columns appeared above a line that said DECISION-READY EVIDENCE. Helen nodded as each page advanced. At the end she thanked Elias for simplifying a complex choice.

"It is clearer," he told Priya afterwards.

"It is," she agreed. "Keep the other version."

"Why?"

"Because someone will ask what the colours mean."

"There's a legend."

"And someone else will remove it."

That evening he opened the workbook again. He looked at the three households not yet included in the register and drafted a query to the council's survey officer. The request took six minutes. He saved it, added the address to the evidence log and sent it before going home. It felt like good work because it was good work. Yet the coloured slide remained on his desk, and he was pleased to have produced something everyone could agree upon so quickly.

In the Upper Registry, a record concerning Elias Rowan gained a new subsection headed PROFESSIONAL CAPACITY.

Cassian Wren admired its proportions. Qualifications, earnings, advancement and the successful application of abstract reasoning could all be represented without the untidy interpretive questions that had troubled the childhood files. He arranged the chart to show a pleasing upward movement.

Ione Thread examined the latest annotation. "What's this about a woman on a train?"

"A socially promising acquaintance," Cassian said. "Potentially beneficial influence."

"Her name?"

"Nadia Bell."

"Then perhaps record that she helped a stranded passenger."

"I'm assessing my charge, not hers."

"You have recorded that meeting her improved his outlook. She's allowed to be a person in her own right."

Cassian frowned. "I could put her name in the margin."

"You could start by leaving it where it is."

He turned back to the chart. He could observe the two of them from the Registry but could neither arrange their next meeting nor guarantee the outcome of this one. They would have to choose what happened without him. He disliked that fact and considered adding a category for it.

It was Nadia who telephoned Elias the following Saturday. She had written her number on the reverse of his railway slip before they parted, and he had spent the intervening week thinking of sensible reasons to ring her. She made the task unnecessary.

"Are you in Saltmere?" she asked.

"For the weekend."

"Good. I have an hour before I need to be at my placement. You can show me the harbour without delivering a lecture about projected tidal heights."

"That's a very specific restriction."

"I have met you."

They bought chips from a shop near the harbour and carried them along the wall. The evening had been hot, but the breeze off the sea was cool enough for Nadia to pull on her cardigan. Fishing boats were settling against their moorings. Beyond the harbour mouth the water took the last of the light and broke it into shifting silver patches.

Elias told her how his father had taught him to read the dark line left by the tide. He showed her the old steps, the joints between sections of wall, the direction of the currents that ran through the harbour entrance. She asked questions that made him explain things he had forgotten were interesting. He found himself using his hands as he talked, drawing the shapes of water in the air.

"You like this," she said.

"The harbour?"

"Understanding it. You look happier than you did with that awful train app."

"It was an awful app."

"A tragedy we'll commemorate every July."

He smiled. They went down towards the low quay. Mrs Vale's cottage stood with its curtains drawn and a small pot of flowers on the step. Elias remembered the winter morning six years earlier: the sodden box, Farid's ladder, the minutes under the bus shelter. He slowed, then walked on.

"I missed an interview near here once," he said.

"Did you?"

"Flooding closed the road. I was eighteen. Thought my whole future depended on getting to one appointment."

"What happened?"

"The university gave me another chance."

"That's good."

"I spent most of that morning convinced they wouldn't."

She looked at him as they walked. "That sounds miserable."

He had expected her to ask whether he had prepared an alternative route, or whether he should have left earlier. He had prepared answers to both questions years before. Instead she had noticed that he had been frightened. He did not quite know what to do with the observation.

"It wasn't my finest day," he said.

"Most of us don't know that while we're having one."

Near the end of the quay a small group of boys were balancing stones on the edge of a mooring post. One pebble fell into the water with a little plop. Nadia watched the circles spread.

"Do you always talk as though someone is marking your answers?" she asked.

"No."

She waited.

"Not always," he amended.

"There we are. Progress."

At the harbour wall he took a folded printout from his coat. He had brought it because she had asked, in their last telephone conversation, what a flood-risk map actually looked like. It showed Saltmere and its surrounding coast in pale blocks of colour, with thin lines indicating roads, drains and projected water levels. He opened it against the top of the wall and held the corners down against the breeze.

"This is an early screening view," he said. "Not an approved investment plan."

"Yes, Mr Rowan. I can see the tiny writing."

"The red areas need urgent attention. The amber ones require more evidence. Green indicates schemes that meet the current criteria. Some of the blue has been left outside the comparison because the property and survey records are incomplete."

Nadia bent closer. Under the light of the harbour lamp, the colours were duller than on his office screen. A block of blue lay below the market road, between the old warehouses and the river outlet. Elias knew the shape from the reports. He had looked at it three times that week without giving it much thought.

"Who is the blue bit on the map?" she asked.

"That's not a person. It's an area outside the current funding screen."

"I know it's an area. Who lives there?"

He followed the blue shape with his finger. There were streets beneath it, roofs and back gardens, a cluster of houses built on ground that had once been an industrial yard. He could picture the narrow shops at the top of the hill and the low road where the drains clogged after heavy rain. He had crossed it on his bicycle as a boy.

"Lowreach," he said.

"Lowreach what?"

"The Lowreach neighbourhood. Houses, mostly. Some older flats."

"Right," Nadia said. "So it's a place."

Elias looked again at the colour. Lowreach had not been made safer or less real by the absence of a comparable survey. It was simply a place his present work could not yet describe well enough to rank. He thought of sending another request on Monday. He thought, too, of the next neat set of slides on Helen's desk.

Nadia waited while he folded the map. She did not tell him what to do with it. After a moment she held out the last chip in the paper, a small crooked thing powdered with salt.

"Are you having that?" she asked.

"No. You can."

"Good. A decision we can both live with."

He laughed, and she took his arm as they turned back towards the lights of the town. The map remained in his free hand. Through the paper he could feel the little raised edges where it had been folded, and somewhere inside those folds was a whole neighbourhood he had only just thought to name.